I cant drag its name through the mud, as the manufacturer makes some great mattressesjust not every mattress it produces. I still think its largely overhyped, and the companys direct offerings are overpriced. To be clear, I havent done a total 360 on Casper as a brand. Of course, the mattress isnt the only perk of joining Costcoyou’ll also get access to reasonably priced bulk items from great brands, including Squishmallow. Even if you were to consider the fee as part of the total cost, a queen mattress, for example, comes to $709still lower than many of our other favorite options, including the Leesa, which will run you into the quadruple digits. But as far as Im concerned, buying a membership, which starts at $60 for a year, would more than pay for itself. The biggest downside is that the Casper Select can only be purchased by Costco members in-store or online. Its not the best mattress Ive ever slept onthat honor goes to the Leesa Hybrid and Tuft & Needle Originalbut it is a really good option, especially for people on a budget. To be honest, I was incredibly sad to let go of the Casper Select. Not only is it cheaper, its also a far and away better mattress.

If it wasnt obvious enough: Id tell anyone who is deciding between the two versions to go with the Casper Select. Though the Casper Select is a Costco-exclusive, it’s well worth it. Costco Mattress Return Policy (With Proof!)

Costco casper mattress review